If you’re even remotely into revolvers—especially classic ones—chances are you’ve heard of the Schofield. It’s a name steeped in history, tied to the Old West, cavalry units, and some of the most iconic moments in American firearm lore. Fast forward to today, and we’ve got the Model 3 Schofield, a modern reproduction that stays faithful to the classic while delivering an experience that today’s shooter can appreciate. Whether you’re a cowboy action shooter, a collector, or just someone who appreciates beautifully made firearms, the Model 3 Schofield deserves a closer look.
In this review, we’re taking a deep dive into everything this revolver brings to the table—from handling and performance to history and practical use. So, buckle in because there’s a lot to cover.
A Look Back and Forward: The Model 3 Schofield
Let’s start by setting the stage. The original Schofield revolver dates back to the 1870s and was a variant of the Smith & Wesson Model 3. It was originally designed for military use, favored for its top-break design and faster reloading capabilities compared to other revolvers of its time.
The modern Model 3 Schofield is a reproduction, primarily manufactured by Uberti (imported by Taylor’s & Co. and others), and it stays true to the spirit of the original while incorporating improved manufacturing techniques. What makes it stand out? Let’s break it down.
| Feature | Details |
| Manufacturer | Uberti / Taylor’s & Co. |
| Action | Single-action |
| Calibers Available | .45 Colt, .44-40 Winchester, .38 Special, and others |
| Barrel Length | 5″, 7″ (commonly available sizes) |
| Capacity | 6 rounds |
| Frame Material | Steel |
| Grip | Two-piece walnut or synthetic depending on the model |
| Finish | Blued, nickel-plated, case-hardened (varies by model) |
| Sights | Fixed blade front, notch rear |
| Overall Weight | Approx. 2.5 to 3.0 lbs |
What Makes the Model 3 Schofield Stand Out?
There are a lot of revolvers out there, both old-school and modern. So, what makes this one worth considering? Let’s break down the stand-out features and real-world experiences that make the Model 3 Schofield such a joy—or not—for firearm enthusiasts.
Iconic Top-Break Design
This is probably the Schofield’s most distinctive trait. Instead of using a swing-out cylinder like modern revolvers, the barrel hinges downward (breaks open) when you release the latch. This simultaneously ejects all spent casings. It’s a cool mechanism, sure, but it’s also practical. If you’re into cowboy action shooting, this is a game-changer for reloading speed.
Beautiful Aesthetics
The Model 3 Schofield is a looker. Whether you choose the blued steel with walnut grips or go full classic with a nickel-plated finish, you’re getting a piece that looks straight out of a Western movie set. The detailing, machining, and finish quality are usually top-tier—especially if you’re grabbing one from Uberti.
Solid Build Quality
These guns aren’t just for show. They’re robust and reliable. The fit and finish are what you’d expect from a high-end reproduction, and they feel solid in the hand. No rattles. No misaligned parts. It’s one of those guns that feels as good as it looks.
Shoots Smooth
When it comes to performance, the Model 3 Schofield holds its own. The single-action trigger is crisp. Accuracy is surprisingly good for fixed sights. And that long sight radius (especially on the 7” barrel version) helps line up your shots. Recoil is very manageable in calibers like .38 Special or even .45 Colt, thanks to the weight of the gun.
Cowboy Action Ready
If you’re into cowboy action shooting, you already know that style points matter just as much as speed. This revolver has both. The top-break makes for quick reloads. The single-action trigger is smooth. And the gun’s design gives it that perfect Old West aesthetic that judges and spectators love.
Pros and Cons: A Quick Rundown
Let’s look at some quick hits—what works and what might make you think twice.
Pros:
- Stunning classic design
- Top-break mechanism is unique and functional
- Good balance and handling
- Available in multiple calibers
- Great for cowboy action shooting or collecting
Cons:
- Fixed sights mean limited adjustability
- Single-action only (not ideal for some users)
- On the heavier side
- Can be pricey, especially nickel models
- Limited modern tactical use
FAQs About the Model 3 Schofield
Is the Model 3 Schofield a good choice for beginners?
It depends. If the beginner is interested in cowboy action shooting or classic revolvers, absolutely. But for someone looking for a modern self-defense revolver, this isn’t it. It’s single-action only, heavier, and not designed for fast modern-style shooting.
Can you use modern ammo in the Schofield?
Yes, but always check with the manufacturer’s guidelines. Most Uberti Schofields are chambered for low-pressure loads like .45 Colt or .38 Special. Avoid +P ammo or hot handloads unless specifically rated for them.
How does it compare to the Colt Single Action Army?
Great question. Both are iconic Old West revolvers, but the Schofield has the edge in reload speed thanks to its top-break design. The Colt SAA wins in cultural recognition and slightly more ergonomic grip angles. It often comes down to personal preference.
Is it historically accurate?
Very much so. Uberti and similar makers do a great job of sticking to the original specs, materials, and finish options. It feels like holding a piece of history.
Is it worth the price?
For the right buyer, absolutely. You’re getting a faithful reproduction with top-tier build quality. It’s not a budget gun, but it delivers value in terms of craftsmanship and collectability.
Conclusion
So, is the Model 3 Schofield worth your time and money? If you’re into classic firearms, enjoy the aesthetics and functionality of Old West designs, or participate in cowboy action shooting, the answer is a resounding yes. It’s not just a firearm—it’s a tribute to an era, a functional piece of history that still delivers great shooting performance today.
That said, this isn’t the revolver for someone looking for a carry gun or home defense tool. It’s a specialty item—a passion piece—and when viewed through that lens, it absolutely shines. The top-break mechanism, the satisfying single-action trigger, and the historical charm all combine to make this revolver something special.
Whether you’re shooting targets on the weekend, competing in cowboy matches, or just admiring it in your collection case, the Model 3 Schofield has a story to tell—and it’s a pretty darn good one.