The Schofield revolver isn’t just another old-school firearm—it’s a true piece of American history. Originally introduced in the 1870s, this break-top revolver quickly gained favor with cavalry units, lawmen, and outlaws alike. Fast forward to today, and the Schofield still manages to stir interest among collectors, cowboy action shooters, and those who simply love a well-made revolver with a classic design.

In this article, we’ll take a deep dive into Schofield revolver reviews, covering everything from its specs and shooting performance to what people love (and don’t love) about it. Whether you’re eyeing one for your collection or just curious about how it stacks up, this guide will help paint a clear picture.

Schofield Revolver Models and Specs

There are a few variations of the Schofield revolver on the market today, mostly reproductions made by companies like Uberti and Taylor’s & Co. These modern versions stay true to the original design but often come with modern materials or slight improvements in finish. Here’s a side-by-side comparison of some popular Schofield revolvers you might encounter:

Each of these is a faithful reproduction of the original Schofield revolver, with some subtle tweaks depending on the brand and model.

What People Like (and Don’t Like) About the Schofield Revolver

The Schofield revolver has a lot of personality—and that leads to some strong opinions. Here’s a breakdown of the common pros and cons, based on user reviews and firsthand experience from enthusiasts.

Things People Like

• Historical Appeal
  If you’re into Old West guns, this one checks all the boxes. The design, feel, and break-top action make it a standout in any collection.
• Top-Break Design
  One of the Schofield’s main selling points is its top-break action. It makes reloading a breeze compared to side-loading revolvers like the Colt Single Action Army.
• Smooth Action
  Many users comment on how surprisingly smooth the hammer and trigger feel, especially for a design that’s over 100 years old.
• Aesthetics
  There’s no getting around it—the Schofield is just plain beautiful. From the long barrel to the elegant curves of the frame, it looks like it belongs in a museum.
• Fun to Shoot
  Even in modern calibers like .38 Special, the Schofield is a lot of fun at the range. The mild recoil and solid construction make it enjoyable for extended sessions.

Things People Don’t Like

• Price
  These revolvers aren’t cheap. Whether it’s a Uberti or a Cimarron, you’re easily looking at over $1,000, which is a hefty investment for a reproduction.
• Weight and Size
  The 7″ barrel models are quite large and heavy. They’re not exactly something you’d want to carry around all day unless you’re in a reenactment.
• Limited Caliber Options
  While .45 Colt and .38 Special are fun to shoot, they might not be as versatile as some modern revolver calibers when it comes to defensive use or availability.
• Not a Workhorse
  Most people buying a Schofield aren’t planning to use it as their primary shooter. It’s more of a fun, nostalgic piece rather than a go-to gun.

FAQs

Is the Schofield revolver good for self-defense?
Not really. While it can technically serve in that role, its size, weight, and cost make it less than ideal. Most people choose it for historical interest or recreational shooting.

Can I use modern ammunition in a Schofield revolver?
Yes, but only if you’re buying a modern reproduction. Always double-check the specs and make sure your ammo matches the caliber and pressure ratings. Most Schofields chambered in .38 Special or .45 Colt are safe for standard pressure loads.

Is the Schofield more accurate than other single-action revolvers?
It depends. The long sight radius of the 7″ barrel models can help with accuracy, but it’s still a single-action revolver. If you’re a practiced shooter, you’ll probably find it reasonably accurate at typical handgun distances.

What’s the difference between the Schofield and the Colt Single Action Army?
The biggest difference is the loading system. The Schofield uses a top-break design with an automatic extractor, while the Colt Single Action Army requires you to open a loading gate and eject each case one at a time. The Schofield is faster to reload.

Is the Uberti version better than the Taylor’s & Co. version?
Both are well-made, and choosing between them often comes down to minor details like finish, grip style, or personal brand preference. Some shooters prefer Uberti for the slightly smoother action, while others appreciate the customer support from Taylor’s.

Conclusion

The Schofield revolver might not be for everyone—but for those who appreciate its rich history, iconic design, and surprisingly smooth shooting experience, it’s hard to beat. Whether you’re a collector, a cowboy action shooter, or just someone who loves classic firearms, the Schofield holds a special place.

While it may not be your first choice for concealed carry or home defense, it’s one of those guns that people don’t just shoot—they admire it. And for many enthusiasts, that’s more than enough reason to own one.